Well, I’m trying to stay away from calling it a “film” look, rather a “cinema look” But, to my eyes the DVX100A and B do much better job at this look, with both the color, shadow detail and contrast latitude. The XL2 also looks a bit too sharp sometimes. I’ve shot similar scenes with both my DVX 100, Canon GL2 and Canon XL2, and I always see better detail in the shadows and highlights compared to the XL2 where these details are either gone to complete black or are blown out. I still love my XL2s and those Canon lenses for a lot of work, but when I’m shooting a narrative “films” I prefer the look of the DVX100.
At this point my only distribution is SD DVDs or the web so from a business point of view, gearing up for HD will be a year of so off for me yet.
For the current film I’m working on, we tested some lower end HDV cameras, which we would need to down convert to SD anyway, and it was quite clear that SD with a great lens looks a lot better than HD (HDV) with a consumer – prosumer type lens.
The guy working down hall in the the next office from me is shooting with the HVX-200 and the images I have seen from that camera have much of the same qualities of the DVX100 but with HD resolution.