“Was the number of missing frames a constant percentage of the total number of frames for each shot?”
Well… the number of frames vary per each individual shot but I don’t know if the percentage was actually equal. I’ll check this out.
“Was your stuff all CG or did you deal with some captured footage?”
We started with captured footage sent by the client and we just composited over some effects stuff, mostly 2D, only here in there some 3D dust particles that were that were rendered as tga’s in 24 frames from 3ds max (which cannot run in 23.98) and composited over the footage in the 23.98 fps AE composition.
“Did you try taking a “bad” sequence and Zip it (not RAR) to see if it was just as bad on their end?”
Didn’t try, but we will although I’m not really sure this has anything to do with the compression. I’m thinking that if the archive were corrupt they couldn’t have opened it in the first place.