That did it, thanks! Turns out I needed to change the iLink setting, which is in the camera’s menu when it’s in playback mode.
Now I have a smaller problem: FCP is making every. single. camera start/stop a separate clip, meaning that there are around 200 clips per tape. What do I do if I want to change this? The article posted below mentions this, but doesn’t say how to get rid of it. Thanks!