-
Working with fcp 24@25 makes video stutter.. (movie editors ??)
Editing a film shot at 24 frames and put on dv tapes. When i use FCP and output with my decklink HD card I can’t make the smoothing 24@25 pulldown work. The picture stutters really bad. However, using firewire and my dsr-11 deck as a converter everything looks nice. This is my first movie project.. Doesn’t decklink support this option ??
(PAL material, Quad G5, Decklink HD Extreme)
Anders
Xraid-Xserve-Xsan-Xeverything
-
5 Replies
-
Interesting. I wondered if the 24@25 pulldown method would only work with firewire out. I wonder if BMD need to implement it in their drivers?
-
Looks like it simply doesn’t work with decklink cards.. VERY annoying. Lets hope the blackmagic guys manage to make it work… please please please
Anders
Xraid-Xserve-Xsan-Xeverything
-
It shutters also with the AJA Io … they don’t understand again upper and lower mixes in PAL …
24@25 in DV should be lower
24@25 in uncompressed should be upper -
So,is the answer that the only way to get a true 24fps edit to tape when working at SD 625 with 24fps film is to output to tape via firewire using System Settings/Playback Control/Pulldown Patteern/24@25 ?
If you try to output via Decklink or AJA you get stuttering when playing a true speed 24fps ETT to 25fps tape.
I guess the answer is to telecine to HD and capture DVCProHD or MotionJPEG @24fps and stay at 24fps all the way or get the rushes telecined to 30NDF digibeta and follow an NTSC SD workflow
-
Yes
Reply to this Discussion! Login or Sign Up