AVCHD is a complex beast, to say the least. There are multiple flavors of it, and newer cameras use newer, updated versions of it…different camera makers use different versions….so that makes this difficult. You might have an older AMA plugin, and it won’t work on the newer format.
But, yes, if you are going to use Avid to import, you must AMA. I don’t think direct IMPORT will even work. AMA link and transcode. If you can’t, see if the most current version of the AVCHD plugin will work on your system. But it’s an old version of Avid, so it might not.
There are external options for converting…EditReady, Resolve, media Encoder.
Things were so much simplier when there weren’t two dozen tapeless formats…a good half dozen variations of AVCHD alone…
Shane
Little Frog Post
Read my blog, Little Frog in High Def