Rendering issues

[Gina Sarentino]

Hi Tim sorry for the late reply,

I ran the tests, here are the results:

I brought the exported 24fps file from Cs5.5 to CC:

1.the timecode goes up to 29frames in the source panel. In the Project window it shows that the video goes up to 24secs and 28frames.

2.When I drag for it to create a new sequence, it creates this :

———————————————————————

I now did the 3rd part. I exported a 23.976 video from Cs5.5, brought it over to CC.

1.In the source panel it goes up to 23 frames, and in the project panel it displays the file as 24 secs 22 frames.

2. I made a new sequence by dragging the file onto the new item tag, here are the results:

I hope this helps, do let me know if anything further is needed.

[Tim Kolb]

It does appear as if exporting in 23.976fps works correctly vs 24 which creates some weird interpretation…

In my professional experience, 23.976 is a far more common frame rate for a number of reasons…possibly why more people haven’t stumbled upon this glitch?

I’d simply stick with 23.976 in your case.

TimK,
Director, Consultant
Video Producer at I-CAR

[Gina Sarentino]

Thanks for the help Tim, just one last question. Do you think this glitch is just a problem with my CC, or is there an issue in the encoding and exporting process?

Also for cinema I need 24fps, do you think itll be an issue if I export it as 23.976fps?

[Tim Kolb]

If the requirement is 24fps, then there is the issue that your original edit sequence is 23.976 in CS5.5…right?

What do you need to do in CC that requires the export from CS5.5 for import into CC?

TimK,
Director, Consultant
Video Producer at I-CAR

[Gina Sarentino]

Im only working in CC, I was just using Cs5.5 to see if I had any issues with my exports there.

Im going to outputting to cinema and I have my 23.976fps with a few 24fps clips from Red camera, that’s basically what my sequence consists of.

[Tim Kolb]

I really don’t follow why you’re moving clips back and forth to test (it seems this bug doesn’t affect your workflow at all so chasing it seems futile), but your edit would be far cleaner if you interpret all your footage to a single framerate…either 23.976 or 24.

If you have a theater venue that requires 24 fps, then using that framerate might be ideal.

TimK,
Director, Consultant
Video Producer at I-CAR

[Gina Sarentino]

Thanks for the help Tim. Ill most likely interpret all the footages to 24fps and go ahead from there.