hvx 200 1080i 24 P NOT Advanced

[Jaenet Guggenheim]

jeremy,

thank you! i am concerned the 2:3:3:2 pulldown is smooth and the 2:3:3:2 isn’t. i shot my dog wagging his tail. it went left, up, right, up. nothing in between.

is 24pa jerkly, as barry green says it is? that’s my big worry. and i know that even if you make a short for a festival, a lot of people still see it only on their tv or computer screen.

xxx

should i use bins with the hd footage i have? i used the camera as a host, let it partition each hd itno 15 slots and filled as i went. that is what i have now, to work with. it does all say vid rate 29.97.

thank you so much!

jaenet

[Jaenet Guggenheim]

okay, here i am in compressor.

i load a clip. click on the HD H.264 60 min. right?

click on the plus sign in the upper right corner of the settings box.

i find the encoder pane.

for file formats, i have alot of choices, but nothing that says dvc pro hd.

i have h.264 for dvd studio pro.

But your email says to

Duplicate the 1080i setting for DVCPro HD

Where????? What box is this in?

In the frame controls pane

I can click frame controls on

I can choose the deinterlace and get reverse telecine

But there is no 23.976 showing anywhere.

Xxxx

Where do I find that dvcpro hd that you tell me to click on? Or to set some tab to?

[Jeremy Garchow]

There’s a seach bubble in the Compressor presets window. Try typing DVCPro

[Jeremy Garchow]

When you shoot 24pA, you remove the p0ulldown before you edit and this process is nearly automatic. You then be left with 23.98 video with no pulldown and no jerkiness. You have to remove the pulldown first, though.

Jeremy

[Jaenet Guggenheim]

thank you so very very much, jeremy

my cousin mark — a great shooter in nyc — walked me through the baby steps inbetween your steps. i finally got my 23.976 clip MIT sound!

i appreciate your help, more than you can know. i have spent weeks and months struggling with this framte rate issue with fcp help, panasonic help, grabbing passing movie people in hopes they know something, and been given tons of conflicting and wrong answers.

you were the first person who could tell me how to get my 1089i24p not advanced footage into fcp. thank you.

of course, now that i finally see it, and see that it’s blurry, i am wondering, “why do people like this?” so after all this enormous effort, i will still shoot with 1080i 24p not normal, and change the frame rates if i have to for festival entries. after all, i KNOW HOW TO DO IT NOW, THANK YOU!!!

you have really really really helped me. thank you.

jaenet

[Jeremy Garchow]

You’re very welcome. Glad you got it sorted out.

Next time, write here a little earlier and save yourself the months of frustration!

Jeremy

[Steven Gladney]

Hi Jeremy,

I was following the thread in which you were helping Jaenet and was hoping you might be able to assist me with something.

Please see the link to my original post below for full details:

https://forums.creativecow.net/readpost/193/872737

Now, while I’m waiting on a response, I’m trying to do a little troubleshooting on my own to see if I can figure this thing out. I’m trying to go through compressor to see if I can reverse telecine my clips that way and I was looking at your thread that you referred to Jaenet.

https://forums.creativecow.net/readpost/8/995940

My question was, when I’m creating the preset in Compressor (I usally never use custom sets, always the presets) do I need to:

1. Change my “Scan Mode:” to progressive or leave it at “Interlaced” (I’m thinking the latter).

2. Do I need to move my “Quality” Scale up to best or leave it at it’s default “Medium” (This time I’m thinking the former, but I’ve also heard stories of how not to touch certain things in compressor because you may think you’re doing some good, but only making it worse).

Any feedback you can provide would be appreciated.

Steven Gladney

Sometimes the obvious is hidden in plain view.

[Jeremy Garchow]

[Steven Gladney] “1. Change my “Scan Mode:” to progressive or leave it at “Interlaced” (I’m thinking the latter). “

You are talking your output scan mode? That should be progressive.

[Steven Gladney] “2. Do I need to move my “Quality” Scale up to best or leave it at it’s default “Medium””

That quality slider is ignored for some codecs and not for others. For dv, that quality slider is ignored. You can put it to best, but it won’t change anything.

Jeremy