Initially did it because there have been some documented errors in Media Managers ability to handle Time remapping. In deleting all the effects it was thought we were actually making it easier for FCP to Manage. However we did try every conceiveable combination: with and without fx (including Time Remaps), Create offline to DV 29.97 then capture as 720p60, Larger handles in thinking that the smaller ones might be hitting time code breaks without capturing the right clip, finally Capturing the ENTIRE Master clip and still not lining up properly in the timeline. Want to do more testing but on a serious time schedule (aren’t they all). In the end the EDL worked out. Very bare bones.
This should be very straight foward; a calculation that FCP should be able to do without so many major mistakes. Granted we havent had to do the offline/online workflow in literally years. We typically work natively at DVCPro HD. No problem. But am still going to look into the issue at length when time permits. Having not handled the project until this point I cant easily trace back any funkiness that introduced itself.