Robin S. kurz
Forum Replies Created
-
[Steve Connor] “based on their own niches”
Yes, I, too, see the painful irony (and freudian projection) in that. ????
– RK
____________________________________________________
Deutsch? Hier gibt es ein umfassendes FCP X Training für dich! -
[Michael Gissing] “So angry…”
Yeah, if not to say FUMING! ????
And it’s so telling to see who so happily chimes in.[Neil Goodman] “I don’t consider the legitimacy of anything he posts any longer.”
Aw, gee. Where that’s of such importance to me! ????… ????
And as opposed to your so relevant, experienced, sober input on the subject of FCP X, seeing that you have so much constructive information, experience and facts to bring to the table, unlike me. Yeah, if anyone here is “legit”, then you.[Neil Goodman] “making these debates not fun anymore”
Where you on the other hand are clearly a party and a half, spewing non-stop “fun” left and right. ????
Funny how when you go off on your Avid tangents, you are so quick to point all perturbed to the “DEBATE” in the title of the forum (conveniently ignoring the “FCP” part) for justification if someone has a problem with it… as long as it suits your narrative, all’s good. But only then of course. Such hypocrisy of a truly angry, frustrated individual, yes…
As so often, if one has no real arguments, get personal and go with the jejune, ad hominem “FANBOY!!1!” approach. Works every time. ????????[Michael Gissing] “a control panel make a difference to the ability to get a decent grade”
Still the exact same solipsism. While a panel certainly is more efficient and highly recommendable, if that’s a significant part of one’s work, it changes absolutely zero of the ability of whoever is using it. It’s in principle no different than a scroll-wheel on a mouse for e.g. scrolling a timeline or window. But I guess using an Alexa suddenly makes you a standout filmmaker after using a GoPro for years, too. And even though Tony asked you and you negated, I guess that is in fact what you meant.
– RK
-
[Tony West] “… and you know what that means?”
That’s an entirely rhetorical question, right? Cuz I’d say that clearly answers itself. ????
-
[Michael Hancock] “Control panels are discussed multiple times”
Oh, right. A full two times according to my search. But even if it were more, a panel has zero relevance in terms of quality of a grade. Because I know PLENTY of people that have jumped on the new-panel-toy-train from BMD and others and you’d still be lucky to get a correct white-balance out of them, let alone an acceptable grade. So pretending or suggesting a PANEL is actually of any substantial relevance as far as the quality of any given grade is concerned, or if the Color Board is of any use (the actual topic) or “a decent tool”, is completely nonsensical…
At the same time no one suggested there wasn’t any room for improvement either. Just as there is with Resolve et al. But also funny how suddenly he usual “The tool doesn’t matter!!” cries can’t be heard this time around either… always interesting how that works. ????
– RK
____________________________________________________
Deutsch? Hier gibt es ein umfassendes FCP X Training für dich! -
[Michael Gissing] “It was just that using a mouse and trying to get speed and finesse with a mouse just isn’t possible compared to a grade panel like my Tangent and Resolves extra functionality.”
Great. Only that this thread has absolutely nothing to do with that. At no point did anyone mention a control panel nor make it any part of their argument, let alone say that a mouse trumps a control panel or the likes. So I’d say you’ve missed the point entirely.
[Tony West] “… or did I misunderstand you?”
I highly doubt it. Nor do I see how anyone could have understood anything else, whether it was intended or not.
– RK
____________________________________________________
Deutsch? Hier gibt es ein umfassendes FCP X Training für dich! -
[Tony West] “Now, if you would have just said, “Hey, going into ripple mode is not that big of a deal” I think most people would have agreed.”
Only that PPro’s “ripple mode” has absolutely nothing to do with FCP X’s “ripple mode”, which is in fact the magnetic timeline. 😉 Only actually comparable to a very very small degree, as Jesús also explains perfectly.
– RK
____________________________________________________
Deutsch? Hier gibt es ein umfassendes FCP X Training für dich! -
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pRZgVZd9UmQ
Replace FCP 7 with any other track based NLE in the example. Nuff said.
And yes, it’s futile Brian. Don’t even try. ????
– RK
Some contents or functionalities here are not available due to your cookie preferences!This happens because the functionality/content marked as “Google Youtube” uses cookies that you choosed to keep disabled. In order to view this content or use this functionality, please enable cookies: click here to open your cookie preferences.
-
[Walter Soyka] “but the wheel also clearly shows why “less blue” brings “more yellow.””
And after having corrected my image, how is that actually relevant information? I don’t even look at the color board while changing values (or after), I look at the scopes. For me, that’s the whole point. I don’t have to know what the opposite of “more yellow” etc. is (even if I do) to get what I’m looking for with the Color Board. I have never heard anyone (except maybe myself) say “I need more green” as opposed to “I have to reduce the magenta”, nor do I see how understanding that they’re both the same is in any way relevant to the result they’re looking for with the Color Board. They just reduce the magenta. Done.
From my experience the Color Board makes color correction understandable without actually understanding it (to the degree you describe) for a lot of people, nor do they need to. Which pretty much describes 99% of the people even doing “color correction” from my experience. Don’t have the first clue about basic color (primary, complimentary etc. yadda yadda) , but they can correct with X in a pinch. Yes, as opposed to with a circle. See it almost daily.
– RK
____________________________________________________
Deutsch? Hier gibt es ein umfassendes FCP X Training für dich! -
Nope, still here.
????
-
[Bret Williams] “3m makes sticky notes.”
*rimshot*
Ok. I LOLed. Good one.