Well, someone did have to say it didn’t they?
The last thing I worked on I did something kind of like that. I exported a proresHQ quicktime with an EDL and used the EDL to make a cutlist from the QT like it was a piece of tape and I was doing a tape to tape correction. It worked okay, but the transitions go a little chewed up, and something in the export process left everything washed out and a bit green (it wasn’t a 709/RGB mixup either, I checked that. I think some codecs just don’t cross convert well). I did a 30 second spot the way I’m suggesting and it looked much better (and graded much easier because I wasn’t constantly cleaning up after the conversion)
Basically I’d like to stay as close to my camera media as possible in terms of quality. I know you don’t lose that much quality with digital, but it is compressed, it’s 8bit color, and comes from a GOP based codec, so I’d like to hang on to any image quality I had to begin with and not be recompressing it too many times.
I’m working on two different projects this way, the first I’m offlining in DNxHD36, so directly exporting that for finishing let alone grading wouldn’t be a good idea, the other one I stayed in XDcam, so it’s still sort of first generation and so I could likely get away with doing that one cutlist style.
Would it be possible to make a macro to accept all my errors and continue re-connecting until everything is online?