I have no idea what I did, but as I continued to tamper and test it started working appropriately. I even tried a preset that I had tried before (which had failed) and it exported super quick (~2 min). It wasn’t a computer restart either; I tried that early on and it did nothing. Right now, my settings are:
H.264
Frame Rate: 29.97
Field Order: Progressive
Profile: High
Level 4.2
VBR 2 Pass
Target bitrate: 2
Max bitrate: 3
Maximum depth and render quality are both checked
So I don’t know what I did to fix this, it’s a mystery. However, I’m still struggling trying to get the video under 25 mb while preserving a decent image. If anyone could help with that, that’d be great. Thanks for the help so far.