Ok, so the way the edges look cut-out is the problem?
What does the background look like? I assume it is not just a flat black like in the image you uploaded. Is it an illustration? A pattern? Text? Photo? Gradient? What colors? How does this photo relate to the background? How is it supposed to look? Is it supposed to look like it is part of the background, or like it is in front of the background?
Can you show the entire image INCLUDING the background it is supposed to integrated into, or at least the problem area?
I guess I would expect a metal object to reflect whatever is in the background, but it is impossible to say anything more based on not seeing the comp that you are having trouble with.