“There aren’t any good, hard-and-fast answers, which you apparently seek. It’s a matter of taste.”
Thanks Dave. That’s helpful. I feel a little insulted, maybe it’s my lack of sleep, but I’m not a moron. The “which you apparently seek” comment is what did it. Not cool.
Here’s some background: decisions have been made that are above my pay grade to take old movies and shows and make them “HD” (ghetto-def). We pillar box some of it (filling top to bottom, sides are matted with a textured pillar box), I’m told to loose the letter box on some of the 4:3 (blowing it up even more) and I’ve even been told to loose the black bars on 2.35:1 John Wayne movies. It looks like ass but as an editor, most of the time I do what I’m told. (I like having a full-time job and I’m currently not interested in returning to the 1099 world.)
So, your explanation of what happens when you resize squares inside of rectangles, and rectangles inside of squares is nothing new to me and wasn’t really helpful. Thanks for trying.
Simply saying there aren’t any good hard and fast answers would have been sufficient.
Bret’s response was the kind of assistance I was hoping for. Thank You Bret.