Thanks for the answers guys, lets see what we’ve got here.
What are your timeline settings in FCP?
HD 1440 x 1080 (16:9) with Anamorphic widescreen.
What’s the pixel aspect ratio in AE for your comp settings?
Square Pixels
If you make a new sequence in fcp and drag one of the AE renders to it, and let fcp conform the sequence to your footage, does it work then
That’s basically what I did with this, but it’s just confused me.
It’s an EXTREMELY good possibility that your 720 footage isn’t 1280×710 at all: it’s probably 960×720, which is proportionately the same as 1440×1080. So you were correct in what you did in FCP
Ah, good! Thanks. It was recorded on a panasonic camera, which does have an issue with the widescreen conversion from what I understand so that would make sense.
You should never Export in AE. You should Render using the AE Render Queue.
Whoops! I didn’t actually ‘export’ in AE, I always use the render cue, so please excuse my sloppy explaination!
And thanks for the heads up on HQ, I just lent towards the one I assumed was higher quality. I guess I can forge ahead with confidence now. Thank you for your help, guys.