Not a big deal, but I’ve used both and for me the 15″ is a lot handier to carry around – editing on the airplane is infinitely easier (I fly coach, so maybe this is just my problem). But if some prefer the 17″, great. If my only editing platform were a laptop, I’d get the 17″.
The people who should be especially dismayed are Sony EX users who want to offload their ExpressCard media to a MacBook Pro, and perhaps check it in FCP. For that purpose, the 15″ is definitely the better choice simply for compactness.
The good news is that the “old” 15″ MBP’s are going to be a lot cheaper. I will definitely be looking for another one.
I am getting used to disappointment as far as upgrades to ProApps. Just out of self-respect, I wish I could agree with Walter (if something else comes along that’s better, I’ll jump). Apple is of course totally aware that the FCP crowd is, by and large, extremely loyal and supportive. After this WWDC’s non-news the loyalists are saying (and perhaps rightly so), “Wait until Snow Leopard,” but after Snow Leopard’s launch, the Apple Loyalist Party will still be hanging in there, keeping the faith that something great is just around the corner at NAB… 2012?
So, part of me would love to jump off the bandwagon NOW in favor of companies that have shown their commitment to NLE/etc. more recently. But in reality, I won’t jump until the gap between FCP and “whatever” gets really gargantuan. I didn’t switch to FCP until it became an absolute necessity. It takes too long to get back up to speed with new software, particularly when there is a whole suite of products involved.
Bob C