Dear Scott,
I am finding your example and this conversation very helpful. I am using fcp5.0.4 and first time importing P2. Have been figuring out this import-problem this weekend and ruling down all other options (flaws in copying the files, storing or naming them, file or shooting formats, custom set-ups, sequence settings) before getting an upgrade.
But now, what became of you? Did you upgrade to fcp 6, how did you do it (did you follow Shane