I don’t think we have a disagreement here. Just talking about different parts of the process and different types of jobs. I’m all for experience. Remember I’m the one who wants the guy hanging the 10k over my head to know what the safety chain is for. 😉
Not exactly off topic to say that this discussion is reminding me of a couple of guys I used to work with who as they got over 50 or so left the business because they said the day to day physical stuff was getting to them. The lucky one now produces and edits video for a government agency. I believe the other one is doing something unrelated. Most of the time it’s hard to say who the smarter one is.