Yeah.. for me it was user error. Final Cut was fine. Turns out that somehow I’d copied across the CONTENTS directory off my firestore drive, but forgotten the LASTCLIP.TXT file. I normally copy over both, but this particular time, I didnt. I spent the better part of two weeks pulling my hair out over this – cursing Apple every 15 minutes for not ‘properly testing Final Cut 6’, and in the end, I was the idiot.
Final Cut needs LASTCLIP.TXT to properly ingest P2 footage, hence the exclamation marks when its missing. Just make sure CONTENTS and LASTCLIP.TXT are in the same directory, and you should be good to go.
BTW. Remember on the Firestore, the CONTENTS and LASTCLIP.TXT folder and file dont show up till you do an ORGANIZE P2 task. And you cant record to the drive again after that. You have to do a format.
Good luck.