Creative Communities of the World Forums

The peer to peer support community for media production professionals.

Activity Forums Apple Final Cut Pro Legacy Still Frame PAIN

  • Still Frame PAIN

    Posted by Kurt Wiley on August 6, 2008 at 4:00 pm

    Why does FCP import stills at a 29.97 frame rate?

    I cannot find any settings in it to change a Still’s video rate to match that of a given Sequence.

    Even if I set the duration of a still for 1 frame, if that still is put into a timeline of a differing video rate (say, 59.94), the still acts as if it has 29.97 frame rate and shows up in timeline as “twos”.

    This is very annoying. How, please, do I get FCP to import a sequence of stills of 1 frame duration to ___match___ a given sequence’s frame rate?

    After Effects does not have this problem. A still’s duration is in frames, no matter what the FPS of the composition / timeline is.

    2d isn’t dead yet!

    Mpigott replied 17 years, 9 months ago 3 Members · 7 Replies
  • 7 Replies
  • Chris Borjis

    August 6, 2008 at 4:51 pm

    It doesn’t really support that. one of the odd issues other NLE’s don’t have.

    you have to create a quicktime from your sequences in either after effects, motion or quicktime pro first.

  • Kurt Wiley

    August 6, 2008 at 4:56 pm

    ??? Does FCP always import stills into itself at 29.97 fps ??

    The problem is FCP is one of the few apps that supports an Uncompressed 8-bit QT codec that is very helpful for making video test content. AE and other apps cannot access that QT codec (it’s another one of these “secret apple things”, I guess).

    I suppose we could use our copy of QT Pro to convert the sequence into something FCP can actually work with.

    2d isn’t dead yet!

  • Chris Borjis

    August 6, 2008 at 5:04 pm

    [Kurt Wiley] “??? Does FCP always import stills into itself at 29.97 fps ??
    The problem is FCP is one of the few apps that supports an Uncompressed 8-bit QT codec that is very helpful for making video test content. AE and other apps cannot access that QT codec (it’s another one of these “secret apple things”, I guess).”

    It just brings stills on at whatever duration they are set for import in the preferences.

    AE can certainly recognize the 8 and 10 bit uncompressed codecs.
    If your talking about AE installed on another machine or pc then you need the free black magic decklink uncompressed codecs installed to recognize those clips on a non-fcp system.

  • Kurt Wiley

    August 6, 2008 at 5:57 pm

    thanks for feedback, Chris.
    I’ve tried very hard to find this “frame rate preference” for still import but cannot do so. I did find the duration setting.

    Is it part of the capture preferences?

    If you can tell steps to access / set frame rates for stills, when imported, that would be very helpful.

    2d isn’t dead yet!

  • Chris Borjis

    August 6, 2008 at 6:57 pm

    the duration setting is it.

  • Kurt Wiley

    August 6, 2008 at 7:22 pm

    Here’s what I found in a tutorial at lynda.com : a way to do this:

    1. Import your stills (they apparently come in at 29.97 no matter what).
    2. Drag the stills to the sequence.
    3. Select all of those stills you just dragged into the sequence.
    4. CNTL-click on selected stills and choose the “Duration (number)…” item in the contextual menua.
    5. You will then see a Duration window appear showing what the stills duration ___for that sequence__ are.
    6. Enter the duration you want for all the items (0:00:00:01 being 1 frame).
    7. The items will “magically” readjust themselves to your chosen default setting.

    The “default” preference is of little help without this “sequence by sequence” trick.

    That appears to solve my problem.
    I’ve posted this to help others stymied by this FCP wierdness. 🙂

    2d isn’t dead yet!

  • Mpigott

    August 6, 2008 at 8:00 pm

    Would this mean that graphics for an XDCAM 24p sequence would suffer
    from the same issue. I posted above in regards to this
    (24p, graphics and pans)

    I will investigate this further….

    [Kurt Wiley] “Here’s what I found in a tutorial at lynda.com : a way to do this:

    1. Import your stills (they apparently come in at 29.97 no matter what).
    2. Drag the stills to the sequence.
    3. Select all of those stills you just dragged into the sequence.
    4. CNTL-click on selected stills and choose the “Duration (number)…” item in the contextual menua.
    5. You will then see a Duration window appear showing what the stills duration ___for that sequence__ are.
    6. Enter the duration you want for all the items (0:00:00:01 being 1 frame).
    7. The items will “magically” readjust themselves to your chosen default setting.

    The “default” preference is of little help without this “sequence by sequence” trick.

    That appears to solve my problem.
    I’ve posted this to help others stymied by this FCP wierdness. :-)”

We use anonymous cookies to give you the best experience we can.
Our Privacy policy | GDPR Policy