[Andy Neil] “Disk Warrior fixed about 30-50 things on my system disk and when I looked at the details, I noticed that virtually ALL of the corruption was centered around the video codecs. Once it repaired those issues, FCPX worked fine.”
Andy,
(I may not have time today, but I will respond to your post about the eSata issues too from the other thread.)
A year later, after numerous problems fixed by Disk Warrior (DW) on 3 different computers, I now believe that Disk Warrior should be included with every Mac and used like Disk Utility and permission repair. In a post here and also offline, I ranted, mostly with Jeremy G about how I believed that FCP X “hosed” my OWC external capture/media RAID drive twice in about 8 months. This drive was only used for FCP X video and I never had any issues when it was the FCP7 drive.
I won’t go into all the details, but the drive became unusable and I spoke with Apple and OWC who had no solutions except to wipe the RAID clean and start over. That worked for a while, but what a pain and then the problem popped up again. I took the suggestion from someone to give DW a try. It took the RAID which again had become unusable, and fixed it. I then ran DW on all my computers and drives and it not only made my wife’s MBP boot up in half the time, but I completely resurrected an old Dual G5 which I had given up on after countless hours of swapping RAM, resetting PRAM, etc., because it “appeared” to be a hardware problem (it was one of the liquid-cooled one which had blown up once under warranty, but fixed by Apple.) No problems with that computer now. My sons use it primarily for Logic 9. I also now run DW on all my drives once every month or two.
I’ve been lucky. I’ve had very few problems with FCP X, aside from the directory corruption, and the eSata mess. In the last 25 years, I’ve been the victim too many times of upgrades which broke more things than they fixed, so I remain happily on OS 10.6.8 and FCP X 10.0.4 because everything works to my satisfaction. I have OS 10.8.3 with FCPX 10.0.8 on a partition, but absolutely no reason to use it.
Anyway, in terms of 3rd party utility software, Disk Warrior is about as good as it gets (Data Rescue 3 just saved by butt from an accidental Carbon Copy Cloner incident, but that’s another story). By the way, the phone support for Disk Warrior is excellent. When I had problems, I got escalated to a senior engineer who was extremely helpful and informative and told me things about eSata which helped and made a lot of sense (I’ll expand on this in the other thread later).
Thanks,
Dave