Activity › Forums › Adobe After Effects › Keyed Subject clothing always flickering
-
Keyed Subject clothing always flickering
Posted by Dan Caz on May 17, 2012 at 4:14 pmI have this reoccurring problem when I am using a green screen and that is when I remove the green and make the adjustments (with keylight)my subject has this flickering effect happening all the time. Especially in darker colors like blue jeans or a black shirt. It’s like the pixels are flashing between dark and light over and over – an unintentional glitter effect. It looks nasty. I actually have better luck keying in premiere pro with the Ultra Key but it seems strange that it should work better than AE…
It’s confusing because my Keylight “screen matte” shows the subject as solid white and the background as solid black so there isn’t any transparency. This flickering isn’t transparency but Im not sure what it is.
Is this a lighting issue or just over-tweaking the key. I try and adjust as little as possible.
Thanks
Randall Sutherland replied 10 years, 8 months ago 8 Members · 10 Replies -
10 Replies
-
Kevin Camp
May 17, 2012 at 4:41 pmyou may be seeing keylight’s despill efforts, where it tries to remove any green screen color that spills on the subject from the screen. this often looks a bit like noise that gets added to the subject.
to double check that that is the issue, toggle the ‘view’ from final result to intermediate and see if the problem persists (at the possible expense of green spill on the subject).
if you still want to suppress spill but try and lessen then noise that the spill suppression is causing, often setting the replacement method (in screen matte settings) from soft color to hard color can help.
Kevin Camp
Senior Designer
KCPQ, KMYQ & KRCW -
Dan Caz
May 17, 2012 at 5:04 pmThanks Kevin, you nailed it. That really cut the noise down.
I’ve seen lots of basic tutorials about keylight and keying in general but they all use these near perfect scenarios where the keying is a one-click solution. I would love to find some more advanced tuts on dealing with more problematic keying for all us young and poor folk lol.
Thanks again!
-
Kevin Camp
May 17, 2012 at 5:21 pmthe foundry has a users guide that has a procedural keying technique that can be pretty useful:
https://www.thefoundry.co.uk/products/keylight/user-guides/
it essentially uses 2 instances of keylight, the first to create a core matte (it calls inside mask), the second to produce the key.
another good technique is aharon rabinowitz’s ‘super-tight junk mattes’ technique that you can find in the ae tutorials here at the cow.
and you can use both techniques on the same key to really define the area that will be affected by keylight.
for more complex spill suppression situations, andrew devis also has a tutorial here.
you can also find several techniques and tutorials here (and on the web) for creating light wrap when you are compositing your keyed elements into a shot/scene, which will usually really help to make it look natural.
Kevin Camp
Senior Designer
KCPQ, KMYQ & KRCW -
Chris Lang
September 10, 2013 at 5:27 pmHi Kevin – I’m having the same issues with flickering even though I have a clean key. I’m using Final Cut Pro and Red Giant’s Primatte Keyer Pro. Do you happen to know where I can find an equivalent option for “Replacement method” there? I’d like to try changing from soft color to hard and see if that helps.
Thanks!
_____________________________________
Chris Lang
Producer/Director
Lifestreams Media, Inc. – A non-profit TV/Film Production Company
http://www.Lifestreams.org -
Jordan Schmelzer
November 22, 2013 at 2:41 pmyup, a simple change from soft colour to hard colour fixed the flicker issue for me. thanks!
Jordan Schmelzer, Editor/DP
-
Kylie Davis
June 19, 2015 at 12:02 amHi Kevin,
I’m experiencing the same problem in Premiere Pro and don’t know how to use AE yet. Can I fix this without using AE? I can’t see a screen matte setting (soft to hard colour) where I am in the keying effect in Premiere Pro.
-
James Clark
October 28, 2015 at 4:15 pmI’m having a similar issue with the final product that’s rendered out of Premiere Pro CC through Media Encoder. I don’t know if it’s in the key that was done in AE or what but there are dancing white lights all over the talent. I changed the color from soft to source to hard in AE with no luck. I lowered the clip white and no dice there. Please help
-
Ellen Yarbrough
November 9, 2015 at 4:43 pmUnder “Screen Matte” go to “Screen Despot White”. you’ll find a selection called “replace Method”, choose “Hard Color” and see what that does. It cleared my chunky video right up.
Ellen
-
Randall Sutherland
November 13, 2015 at 3:00 pmI use Breeze Software. What are the exact steps to eliminate flickering and hair (gray or blond) from disappearing into the background?
How do you go from soft to hard color – software – camera – how do you do this adjustment – step by step please?
Any other suggestions would be appreciated also – but please be exact as I’m just starting to grasp this idea.Screen – lighting – software ? I need the best set up to eliminate these issues ASAP – HELP !
Randall
Reply to this Discussion! Login or Sign Up