-
HDV 24p files in Premiere Pro CS3
G’day
I have footage made using a JVC GY-HD100 with Focus Enhancements DR-HD100 at 24p which will not, whatever I try, display correctly in the editor. I have made HD 24p presets with several combinations of parameters, even trying 30p presets, all performing in the same fashion.
In short the video appears “fast” and advances in relation to the audio, progressively worsening with time. Also, the files show up in the project panel 29.97fps even though they are 24p. I have tried disabling the 3:2 pulldown and assigning 23.97fps rate with no change in performance. When replayed in the camera the clips are reported as 24p and perform fine.
My documentation seems to not perfectly match the software, and I have tried MANY combinations of settings, I’m sure I’m missing something simple. Any ideas, please?
Thanks
J. L. Jones -
1 Reply
-
I have this same setup. Are you working in a HDV 24p project?
This was at first CS2 issue when JVC first came out with the 24p settings and premiere could only do 30p. Then the fix was to unlink audio video and change the video speed to 80% and relink audio & video.
While shooting 24p sounds cool, it’s not unless you REALLY need to (say for film output). You need to read Bob Zelin’s article on why not. There’s also plenty of 24p discussion in the forums to also back this up. The debate goes both ways. For me, I shoot 30p. It looks close enough to film, but works well in all 60p/60i/30i/30p projects. 24p is a can of worms when you try to mix it into anything… rather than working in JUST 24p and nothing else (from recording the file files (in 24p), to editing the project (24p) & final product (24p output).
Tim Robinson
tim@erobinsons.com
Pride-Mobility-Products
Corporate Video Editor
Reply to this Discussion! Login or Sign Up