[Dennis Dean] “I’ve tried dropping the setting onto the clip – but it adds the new setting, doesn’t get rid of the old setting.”
Drop the new setting ONTO the old setting.
[Dennis Dean] “Seems like I should be able to drop the clips onto an empty batch without a setting being automatically assigned.”
When I bring in new clip into compressor (ver. 3.5.3) there are no settings on it, the clip just say’s “drag settings and destinations here”. To apply the same setting to multiple clips, I highlight each of them and drop the setting to one clip and they all get it. Check Compressor>Preferences for the “Default Setting” option, mine is set as “none”. Presumably, you have your preferred DVD Setting set as the default.
To do what you want, as things are now (bunch of clips with unwanted settings)- select all clips, control-click (right-click) and select “remove all targets”. Then drop the new setting to one clip (while all the clips are still highlighted) and they will all get the new setting. If you need to apply a new destination to all clips as well, highlight the setting on each clip, right click and select “destination>xxxxx”. This will apply to all.
or
Highlight all clips, remove all targets, add destination, highlight all settings, right-click one and choose “change setting” to change all the clips settings at once. But changing the Compressor>Preference>Default Setting, to “none” is probably the best way to go about it.