After Effects Course – Final Movie – Please respond

[Nate Vander plas]

Nice job! I’ve considered trying that HP commercial effect myself. Looks good! I especially like the way the light reflects off the pictures- how exactly did you do that? Good rotoscoping too. I think my favorite was the guy with the beard who wrote with his finger.
Some criticisms that may or may not be under your control:
-the graphics did not always match the hand movements
-I didn’t particularly like the light streaky effect with the guy outside, but that’s a matter of taste
-the overall video quality is not the greatest, but I realize this is primarily a graphics piece and you are not necessarily a videographer
-finally, everything seemed a bit dark to me, especially for such an upbeat, happy song
Otherwise, great job. I hope you were looking for (constructive) criticism cuz that’s what I assumed. Keep up the great work! I love to see other people’s stuff!
Nate