-
Top Quality for HD footage on DVDs
Hey all,
It seems that I can never match the clarity and quality of the picture when I burn my projects to DVD – I’m working with footage shot on Sony EX-1.
I send it to compressor and set it on DVD Best Quality and make sure the Encoder is maxed out.
I select SD DVD because the HD DVD’s don’t play on DVD player.
Is it even possible to get the picture on SD DVD’s to look like they do as on my computer with the XDCAM EX 1080p24 (35 Mb/s) codec? any way to burn a dvd with a bit rate as high as 36,641?
If anyone has any insights or links to some good reading for this art i would REALLY appreciate it because I’ve been struggling with this for some time and it’s very timely to experiment .
Thank you!
-
6 Replies
-
“Is it even possible to get the picture on SD DVD’s to look like they do as on my computer with the XDCAM EX 1080p24 (35 Mb/s) codec?”
Are you trying to burn your DVD for TV or computer viewing?
If it’s for TV viewing, are you judging the quality of your image on a TV or a computer screen. It will not look crisp on a computer screen, especially if you play the DVD in full screen.
If you want to use it for computer viewing only, you can burn H.264 files to a DVD in DVDSP. Use Compressor to encode the file. You can encode to an HD resolution if you’d like. Then bring that file into DVDSP and author as you would with MPEG files, although I think you’ll have to change some settings in DVDSP Preferences. Have a quick look at the manual.
The downside to authoring H.264 to a DVD is that it will only play on computer that support that codec. It should work in a Mac, I’ve done it before. Not sure about PCs though. The benefit is that the image looks amazing.
Robert J. Grauert, Jr.
http://www.robgrauert.com
command-r.tumblr.com -
No I am not expecting any miracles…?
I am trying to make sure that I’m not missing any steps for maximizing the quality on DVD.
Thanks.
-
you might be missing one.
go into the compressor preset you used.
set the resize filter quality to best.
that should make a difference.
-
[Ry Tullis] “any way to burn a dvd with a bit rate as high as 36,641? “
Not if you want it to play back in a DVD player. Usually max bit rate should be around 7.5 mbps, min around 6.5. Once you start going higher than that dvd players will start to get angry.
Joey
-
Dave, what a witty and insightful response you have. I’m sure that will keep anyone with a real question from thinking that the COW is here to help. How dare they not know the answer before posting here.
I’m sure your experience and vast wealth of knowledge must be just flowing out of you. I bet you are just a joy to work with in person.
Jim McNally
The Commercial Factory
http://www.commercialfactory.com -
Dave, Your point was well taken and your sarcasm overlooked, but as you are now making false claims about me (intentional or not) I feel I must clarify (in similar jeering style, for fun):
“High school and college students are one thing. People who claim they’re pros are another.”
Yes, because I clearly stated in my post that I am a pro.
“If I had a dime for every post from someone making a living as a shooter/editor that asked, ‘how come my DVD doesn’t look as good as my original video?’ ”
Yes, because as all random strangers on the internet would know, I am making my living by shooting and editing (Actually, I am a composer. I enjoy working with video as a hobby.)
“You’d think people who make video — which they in turn are paid for — might have the knowledge to figure out that head-scratcher on their own. I have no compassion for them. ”
Yes, because I always make sure to run all the monetary logistics of my projects by Dave LaRonde and he would know the masses and masses of cash I’m piling up over here.
In conclusion, we return to the old saying: if you have nothing nice to say, say nothing at all, UNLESS of course you’re going to make a good point while doing so and it doesn’t matter how sarcastically you deliver it because you’re not a real person in essence, just a bunch symbols on a screen.
PS – Thank you everyone, including Dave, for their input on this topic.
Reply to this Discussion! Login or Sign Up