Here’s the thing, I’m in EXACTLY the same predicament. Prior to MC 6.x, I was using the Matrox MXO2 Mini, which was totally awesome. In MC 5.x it worked like butter and was totally reliable. However, in MC 6.x, the system changed somehow and the drivers are no longer as good. The Matrox MXO2 mini is now almost unusable when doing trims with the audio scrubbing enabled in MC. Outside of that it works great in MC.
The Matrox also works awesomely with PP CS6. I was using it a couple weeks ago to cut some 5k RED Raw files natively without transcoding and you would have thought I was using a DV sequence or something, it was so silky smooth. Totally awesome. I was impressed as could be.
Unfortunately, since Avid is my primary NLE, I switched over to a Blackmagic Intensity Pro card. This card works great with MC 6.x. The scrubbing is pretty decent. I can trim now while in audio scrub mode (still not perfectly, but it’s pretty good. Splitting hairs kinda stuff). All would be great, except this card doesn’t do any up or down converting, so it’s basically worthless when trying to use CS6 with footage larger than video frame sizes.
I can create a 1080p sequence for my RED Raw footage and get it to display from the record side, but you can no longer see your footage from the source side in Premiere Pro. Worthless.
So I’m looking for something that will make me happy in both applications too. I’m currently looking at the AJA Kona cards. Anybody have experience using these cards in both systems? Or the AJA I/O Express? Again, any experience in both systems?
Thanks a million in advance.
Michael, does the more expensive BM card work in both systems? I’d be willing to drop a bit more coin if it works.
Chris Conlee
MacPro 4,1 (8 core)
OS X 10.7.4
24Gb RAM
GTX285 (latest CUDA drivers)
MXO2 Mini or BM Intensity Pro (latest drivers)