Hello Philip and welcome to the Cow Audio Forum.
You present a provocative question. Every test of monitors I’ve done has been with sources I know; a handful of CDs that I have listened to a lot and know very well.
Yes, once you have put the money down for something, you are involved. That doesn’t invalidate the choice necessarily. A lot still depends on your experience. For example, I have seen people rave about a mic or piece of gear they have bought. I have been reviewing gear professionally for over 20 years for trade magazines. I may know that the piece they are talking about is OK, but not as good as another. Usually, when I ask them if they have heard the better gear they haven’t, so they don’t have the experience to make the comparison. Regardless, the Internet provides them the ability to make their opinions known in a text block right next to mine.
Because I do this professionally, I have to be VERY careful and VERY up front about what I say about a piece of gear. When I see, “Ty Ford LOVES these (whatever)”, and I never said I “Loved” them, I have to correct that. Companies want me to write glowing things about their gear, but they get upset if I write with enthusiasm about their competition’s gear.
The boards are also populated by marketing and counter-marketing types who are on the web to sway opinions.
So, yeah, you’re at a disadvantage. My suggestion is to not put a lot of weight on what anyone says in a forum unless you know their credentials, and then still don’t use them as your main criteria. The AES has trade shows once a year. The next one will be in NY in October 2009. Most of the better monitor makers have separate rooms in which you can hear their speakers. Go. Bring CDs you know. Listen. Compare.
Some retailers have listening rooms. You want to be a little careful about them. Some are great, others just want to sell you the popular monitor with the biggest margin for profit. Having a solid relationship with someone at the shops is VERY important. If you have that and are serious and up front with them, they may let you try a pair and make changes as long as you’re not just trying to jerk them around.
Hope this helps.
Regards,
Ty Ford
Want better production audio?: Ty Ford’s Audio Bootcamp Field Guide
Watch Ty play guitar