Hello Nat,
What happens when you normalize your denoised track in Soundtrac? That’ll tell you how well your noise reduction efforts were. 🙂 I’ve been down that road. Apply enough noise reduction and everything gets quiet. When you gain it up, the noise reduction isn’t as much as you thought.
You may have gotten it right. I’m just sharing my past experiences.
Brian’s thinking process is very ingenious and we’re lucky to have him on this board. As I mentioned, the wider the spectrum of the noise and the more it occupies the same frequencies as the voice frequencies, the less effective I expect this approach to be.
Roland used to make a simple outboard denoiser hardware box that worked pretty darn well. The new iZotope hardware and software work pretty well, but I’m unsure how much better they may be than the software tools you already have.
Last thing to try would be to find someone with a CEDAR system and have them do a pass though…oh, right, then there’s the reshoot filter.
Regards,
Ty Ford
Want better production audio?: Ty Ford’s Audio Bootcamp Field Guide
Watch Ty play guitar