OK, everyone has had a go-round. Now let me.
Good mixers like the 302 and 442 with limiters absolutely can improve your audio, provided you know how to use them.
Mixers are more than knobs that let you vary the volume.
1. They let you vary volumes without shaking the camera or getting in the way of the camera op.
2. You may need to do that a lot with some people. I ride gain even if one person is talking if their voice fades on the end of each line. You can only do this in a relatively quiet environment, otherwise you bring up the ambient noise.
3. Mixer preamps (good ones) sound better than camera preamps.
4. Good mixers have input transformers that scrape off RF before it get into your audio.
5. Good mixers have limiters that allow you to record hotter, keeping your audio further above the noise floor without distorting.
6. Good limtiers have EQ that lets you roll of LF HVAC noise before it gets into your audio.
7. Good mixers have mulitple outputs so you can feed more than one camera, or separate recorder simultaneously.
8. Good mixers make your sound better. If they didn’t pros wouldn’t use them.
In addition to a good mixer (as in a piece of equipment), a knowledgeable person operating the mixer can get much better audio than simply plugging the mics into the camera.
I’m thinking two things about the original poster’s problem. Something may be misadjusted, but more likely than not, the outbursts are just too loud for the settings. This happens. It’s like shooting someone with bright backlighting and trying to get a good exposure on their face when it’s in the shadow. The dynamic range of the light to dark is too great for the camera.
BTW, I have never hear a voice get louder on a lave if the lav is placed farther down the chest.
Regards,
Ty Ford
Want better production audio?: Ty Ford’s Audio Bootcamp Field Guide
Watch Ty play guitar