• Apple Final Cut Pro Legacy

  questions concerning workflow, renders, and outputs.

  Posted by Ericsson Chu on November 1, 2007 at 1:45 am

  Hi everyone, this looks like a great forum with a lot of information flowing around. I was wondering if anybody could answer a few questions I had. I’ve attempted to be specific as possible, but please let me know if any further information is needed. thanks! B)

  Just to clarify my situation – I’m importing mini dv footage, but i’m altering that pretty much extensively with many layer composites (up to 20) , some in program effects, after effects graphics, adding in MAYBE some maya, and various plugins such as boris red, magic bullet, twixtor, natress, art studio, etc.. Would maintaining a sequence suited for dv ntsc make sense if maintaining those effects, graphics, and overlays’ vibrancy, motion, and color is key? Or should I then change my sequence settings to animation or uncompressed 8 or something other to retain graphic quality? Logically I feel it wouldn’t hurt to upcompress mini dv, while it would hurt downcompressing graphics to dv… but i’m not sure. I know if I’m working with primarily dv footage, garbage in garbage out, stick with a dv codec through and through, but in this case, where i’m altering the footage so extensively… I’m just not sure.

  Then, also, I am looking at my render settings. Logically (again), I should be able to set my render to 25% res, draft quality, low-normal motion estimation, work in that, and export at high quality with equal result to as if I were rendering at the highest settings possible (while cutting). But, looking around, I’ve heard different – apparently I will lose quality by doing so (rendering at low quality, then exporting), and I should maintain a high render setting throughout. I was wondering if you had any definitive input into this? As a possible solution – could I work around it by working purely at low quality render until I achieve a polished rough cut or picture lock, AND THEN re-rendering everything out high?

  Last question – what should my final export setting be to maintain highest possible quality (near lossless if not in fact lossless) with no screw ups or glitches? I want a pristine master (basically I want what I see is what I get) that I can, if necessary, then downcompress for either internet (h264) or dvd without too much headache. I guess the answer to this depends on the answer to my first question though (i.e. uncompressed 8 bit should export to uncompressed 8 bit, animation to animation), but correct me if I’m wrong.

  thanks,
  e

  Tom Meegan replied 18 years, 6 months ago 2 Members · 1 Reply
• 1 Reply

• 

  Tom Meegan

  November 2, 2007 at 9:57 am

  Eric:

  GIven your situation I would work in uncompressed or ProRes. In FCP I’d avoid the animation codec, although your mileage may vary.

  ProRes HQ would be my first choice

Reply to this Discussion! Login or Sign Up