-
24pA in fcp- began sequence w/ wrong timebase!
OK. I’m working on a feature doc. and it is all shot on the DVX100 in 24pA. Now, I recently got funding (and therefore a new Mac/ FCS) and without exploring the 24pA issue fully I:
-
4 Replies
-
Sorry I couldn’t really follow your train of thought there. Can you boil it down to the most important question?
-
Sorry-
Sometimes one is unintelligible when disaster approaches. I have settled a couple of these issues (I think…) but here’s a less convoluted description of a deeply convoluted situation: In essence, I have two related problems A & B, below. Feel free to comment on either.A. I shot 24p Advanced, but captured in FCP without pulldown, so these clips (about 70 hours worth) are 29.97fps. I have been editing them in a 29.97 timeline. I have 2 main questions: Whether to remove pulldown and switch over to a new 23.98 sequence, and if so, how? And, if so, are there dangers (see “B”)
I do not know whether the project will be transferred to film but it’s possible (not necessarily likely, but possible).B. The factor that introduces confusion is that my main sequence (due to some kind of corruption) got lost this past week. In the meantime(while the sequence was lost), I experimented with pulldown removal with several clips in the project. Now, I found the lost sequence last night, which is good, but these few clips that I made 23.98 were reading as “offline” in the sequence (which, again, is a 29.97 timebase) . Also, the audio was out of sync (in the entire sequence). So I recaptured these clips (without advanced pulldown removal) and edited them back into the sequence. So it all looks fine, but the audio is still out of sync- by 5 frames consistently through the whole 58 minute sequence .
So, I don’t know if the sync issue is truly related to the pulldown removal (although I remember seeing a guy on some board with a similar problem and he had the same sync issues). But it is certainly a problem.
Sorry for a lengthy and confusing post but I want to disclose as much info as possible so that as people are responding I don’t find myself introducing “new” symptoms/ factors.
Forgive me for muddying the waters…mh
-
Bottom line- switching to 23.98 at this stage in the project will take a major amount of time and effort and gain you little *unless* you want to do a film output.
-
Thanks for the reply- not changing to 23.98 is a relieving idea.
Any thoughts on the sync issue? Every sequence is off by 5 frames. When I began having problems a few days ago I trashed my preferences- and then restored them, of course. Is there anything I may have missed that would cause the sync to get off like this?
Of course, I can manually fix it by dragging the audio over 5 frames, but that might be a really bad plan…thanks,
mh
Reply to this Discussion! Login or Sign Up