-
Video card survey: SVP11 and CUDA acceleration
Hi
There are mixed reviews by early adopters of SVP11 that the preview lag issue has been addressed, with some reporting success with both ATI and NVIDIA based cards, and others noting none.
I mainly edit in HDV and in a single track project in SVP10, it edits like butter, but the preview does get laggy once multi-cam in Ultimate-S is enabled, but I can usually edit in preview/full most of the time.
As I edit in multi-cam mainly using Ultimate-S, I would be interested to get a cross section of the video card SVP11 users have installed. I would also be interested to know if the amount of installed RAM on the video card has a bearing on performance.
I intend to replace my video card, but if it is going to have limited benefit, I am looking at perhaps going down the GearShift path. So perhaps you could kindly assist me by responding to the following questions (aimed at SVP11 users):
Do you experience preview lag? Yes/No
Are you editing multi-cam? Yes/No
Edit format: HDV/AVCHD/AVI/DV
Multi-cam tool: Ultimate-S/SVP11
Make and model of your video card:
Amount of RAM installed on your video card:Thanks in advance
My system specs: Intel i7 970, 12GB RAM, ASUS P6T, Vegas Pro 10e (x32/x64), Windows 7 x64 Ultimate, Vegas Production Assistant 1.0, VASST Ultimate S Pro 4.1, Neat Video Pro 2.6
-
5 Replies
-
I’ve given my thoughts many times already, so at the risk of boring everyone, I found multicam editing on Vegas 9 and 10 very smooth, even with 8 tracks of video and computer specs very similar to yours. In 11, it was so slow and choppy that it was almost unmanageable. I had video with lots of motion that I was cutting between four tracks and I was utilizing GPU acceleration with a GeForce GTS 450, but it didn’t help. It sure helped with mpeg2 rendering, it seemed, because rendering a 90 minute video for DVD took only about 30 minutes.
I switched back to Vegas 10 because of that and other issues, which were just as maddening if not more so. When they fix these problems with 11 I’ll gladly switch back.
Ok, I’m repeating myself again, but I just want to see if anyone else is having this problem-Vegas 11 made ALL my avi footage-thousands of media-and made them the incorrect aspect ratio. It’s 1440×1080 footage with an aspect ratio of 1.33. It made all that footage have an aspect ratio of 1. Not the preferences for the project, but the media itself, so I was having to right click on every piece of media and change the aspect ratio. Is there some setting in Vegas I can change for that, or did Sony royally screw that up?
For those and still other reasons, all Vegas 11 is is a loss of features and functionality. Maybe Sony will roll out an upgrade in a month if we all let them know what the issues are.
-
Hi,
Do you experience preview lag? Yes – but overall it’s much better than 10. I can preview in optimized mode, which was not possible for me in 10.
Are you editing multi-cam? No – but I am having lags when 2 tracks are combined through transparency (should be the same issue, as there are twice more data to handle in both cases)
Edit format: AVCHD
Multi-cam tool: none
Make and model of your video card: GTX460 (don’t remember the brand. Asus or Gigabyte)
Amount of RAM installed on your video card: 2GBFrom my GPU perf monitor, I can see that lag happens even with the GPU is loaded at 6-10% only (a pitty), and the video card RAM is far from being saturated. So it looks like the bottleneck is the bus speed to transfer data between CPU and GPU (because the CPU is not fully loaded as far as I remember).
@Angelo: I don’t have the scripting API doc with me, but I am pretty sure it lets you access the aspect ratio property of an event. I am amazed that Vegas modified the input media, but if it does so, then changing this property from a script will probably update the media?
Hope this helps,
Frédéric—
Want to Match Colors between clips? new plug-in here.
Check GPU-powered FBmn Software plug-ins to fix White Balance and Exposure issues.Want to learn on Sony Vegas Event Pan/Crop tool? Watch my tutorial.
Or about Keyframes? Watch this one. French version here. -
Along with the other problems I’m having with Vegas 11, I’m too fed up with it to take you up on that script. Thanks for the offer, though. But when I reinstalled Vegas 10, all that same footage that Vegas 11 made an incorrect aspect ratio for is now in its correct aspect ratio. Go figure, Sony made an update that undoes my work.
-
Do you experience preview lag? No
Are you editing multi-cam? Yes
Edit format: AVCHD
Multi-cam tool: Ultimate-S
Make and model of your video card: 2-ASUS GTX-460
Amount of RAM installed on your video card: 768MB on eachVERY similar system to yours. Windows 7 Pro (not ultimate)
I have never been an early upgrader. I usually wait for feedback. But with this upgrade to 11, my multicam is so smooth it feels like Christmas!
Jeff
Windows 7 64-bit, ASUS P6X58D, i7 960 3.20GHz, 24.0GB DDR3, 12TB connected storage
http://www.narrowroadmedia.com -
I experiance bad lag on preview and the time line as it moves in surges.
yes editing multi cam 4 sony ex1 mxf footage, ACHD and m2t HVR V1e
I have 2 nvidia 580gtx with 3gb dd5 ram each! 6GB in sli 1024 cuda cores.
have i7 980i hex core 4.1ghz rendering on 12 threads.
12gb ramproject lenght 2.45 hrs
render time GPU 3.50hr CPU with GPU accelaration turned off 1.56hr
very buggy want my money back!
Reply to this Discussion! Login or Sign Up